
So, how are we doing? On April 14, as his fifth academic year at Maxwell neared
its end, Dean Mitchel B. Wallerstein invited the entire School community to join
in an exercise in self-reflection when he delivered a “State of the School”
address. Reprising, in some respects, the “vision statement” he gave during his
first year as dean, Wallerstein systematically revisited goals he set back then,
and assessed the progress that had been achieved. He also delineated many of the
challenges and new opportunities the School now faces.
The Academic Mission
“How have we fared academically in the past five years?” he asked. “The
first—and perhaps the most important—thing to say is that we have continued to
strengthen an already impressive and dedicated faculty. Maxwell has always been
known for its excellent teachers, and this is nowhere more true than at the
undergraduate level, where our faculty continues to play a central role—teaching
more than 5,000 students each year.”
On the undergraduate front, the dean noted that slightly more than 50 percent of
Syracuse University’s arts-and-sciences students receive their bachelor’s
degrees
each year in the social sciences that are part of the Maxwell School. The MAX
courses—interdisciplinary lower-division courses reminiscent of citizenship
curricula from years past—“continue to be among the most heavily subscribed
courses for first year students,” he said, “and they are without question the
most successful, interdisciplinary pedagogical activity in Maxwell, or any other
part of Syracuse University for that matter.” He noted, as well, new efforts to
better engage undergraduates in the life of the School and alumni body: letters
he sends to new social science majors, and to those students when they graduate;
upgrading of the Undergraduate Study Center in Eggers Hall; and the recent
introduction of an electronic newsletter for Maxwell undergraduate majors.
In the doctoral programs, Wallerstein noted excellence within the departments,
and yet added that, in many cases, top-notch students are choosing to attend
other institutions, largely due to lack of adequate graduate funding. “To
recruit outstanding students,” he said, “we need, among other things, to offer
more financial support.” To address this need, scholarly departments are
restructuring the way they offer assistance to students, while, on the other
hand, the current fund-raising campaign emphasizes additional fellowship and
scholarship resources.
In the professional degree programs—public administration and international
relations—the dean drew attention to the Executive M.P.A. degree (successor to
the M.A. [P.A.] degree offered through Executive Education), which has been
“revamped . . . to make it more responsive to the needs and interests of the
many midcareer students who come to Maxwell from around the world, as well as
from across the U.S.”
He offered a warning, too: The fields of public affairs and international
affairs are changing and there are a growing number of high quality schools that
have been established recently in Europe, Asia, and elsewhere. “As we look
ahead, it will be important to find ways to understand the changes that are
taking place in the public affairs field and take proactive steps to insure that
Maxwell continues to attract the ‘best and brightest’ students,” Wallerstein
said.
What’s
New
During the past four-plus years, the Maxwell School has created new academic
programs, partnered with other Syracuse University schools and colleges to
create new interdisciplinary institutes, and created new outreach programs
(scholarly and/or intellectual programs that not only inform, but that spread
the Maxwell name and reputation to new quarters). Among those he listed:
The Institute for National Security and Counter-Terrorism. Co-sponsored
by Maxwell and the College of Law, INSCT continues to expand its national and
international reputation and the scope of its research activities. In addition,
it hosts the new advanced-study certificate in security studies, awarded last
year to 29 Maxwell students.
The Institute for the Study of the Judiciary, Politics and the Media.
Co-sponsored with SU’s College of Law and the Newhouse School, and with support
from the Chancellor’s Initiative fund, IJPM focuses on the pressures and
political attacks on the federal and state judiciary that have increased in
recent years as a result of media coverage of controversial issues
New Master’s Degree Programs. Maxwell and Newhouse now offer a dual
degree program in public diplomacy (for more on that, see
this story) and a joint master’s degree
in history and documentary filmmaking, both of which welcomed their first
entering classes for the 2007-08 academic year. The School is also in the final
stages of developing a new master’s degree in public health (which will be
offered jointly with Upstate Medical University in Syracuse); helping to
establish a new master’s degree in fine arts administration (housed in SU’s
College of Arts and Sciences); and developing a new interdisciplinary Ph.D.
program in environmental policy and science with the SUNY College of
Environmental Science and Forestry.
Policy Breakfast Series. Co-sponsored by Public Agenda and hosted by
Robert Siegel, host of NPR’s All Things Considered, the Policy Breakfasts
present prominent policy makers (e.g., Paul Volcker, Brent Scowcroft, Desmond
Tutu, Charles Rangel) to invited audiences of influential leaders in New York
City. These are programs that are educational and that help raise the School’s
profile.
The Maxwell Poll. The annual Maxwell Poll on Civic Engagement and
Inequality “has become a national reference source on the twin subjects of civic
engagement and attitudes toward social inequality,” Wallerstein said.
International Relationships. The School has deepened its long-standing
relationships in Korea, China, and India. Last year, Maxwell launched an
India-based midcareer program for senior leaders from the elite Indian
Administrative Service. Meanwhile, Maxwell brought to Syracuse an “extraordinary
group of rising young political leaders” from the Middle East to learn about
democratic governance. Maxwell was selected by the U.S. State Department to run
this program.
Challenges We Confront
When Wallerstein turned his attention to the challenges facing the School, he
hit upon two broad dynamics: change and competition.
“The
field of public affairs, broadly defined, is changing and globalizing,” he said.
“. . . We are seeing new, high-quality public policy and public management
institutions established in Europe, Asia, and now in the Middle East. In some
cases, these new schools are being funded directly by—or at least, have the
explicit blessing of—their national governments, many of which have recognized
that the social, economic, and political pressures that accompany modernization
and development are creating entirely new demands that they are ill-equipped to
handle. In other cases, these institutions are being established on a private
basis, and some already have capitalization that exceeds our own.”
Wallerstein welcomes such a challenge as an opportunity to “fine-tune our own
programs and to become more innovative. . . . We ignore these trends at our own
peril.”
Competition takes many forms, student recruitment being only one. The dean also
spent a considerable part of his address discussing the “quality, energy, and
commitment” of the Maxwell School faculty. Given the growth of existing programs
and introduction of new programs, “the sheer scope of [faculty] activity is
without precedent, even by the ambitious standards of the Maxwell School!” he
said.
“I recognize full well the importance of compensating our faculty competitively
and, of course, retaining them. This is one of the most difficult challenges
that I (and every dean) faces, especially in today’s often overheated academic
job market.” Wallerstein committed himself to finding ways to provide salary
resources, so as to retain an accomplished and prestigious faculty—a faculty
where, “like Garrison Keillor’s mythical town of Lake Wobegon, ‘all the children
are above average,’” Wallerstein said.
At present, he admitted, the School is sometimes put in the position of
responding ad hoc to impending faculty departures, doing its best, day by day,
to retain the very best faculty members already on hand. Strategically, he said,
the goal must be instead to “consistently offer market-competitive salaries.”
Other challenges? The dean made an intriguing mention of physical space.
Although Eggers Hall is only 14 years old, it is totally full and already the
School has begun moving units into other University facilities. If a donor
emerges, Wallerstein said, the School is prepared to develop plans for “Maxwell
III.”
Opportunities on the Horizon
Philanthropy was also paramount when the dean turned his attention to the future
and new opportunities that await. His chief priority, he said, is to complete
the current fund-raising drive—Maxwell’s part of the larger Campaign for
Syracuse
University.
(For his comments on that priority, which he termed a “no-brainer,” see the box
at right.)
Beyond the campaign, Wallerstein has his eye on new opportunities to expand the
Maxwell School’s programming away from campus.
“It is necessary for us to recognize that globalization is not just an economic
and political reality; it now extends to virtually every dimension of human
interaction—including higher education,” he said. “While the scope and quality
of the U.S. higher education system is still superior to that of most other
parts of the world (other than Europe), the days of unchallenged U.S. dominance
are nearing an end.”
Fortunately, the School already has forged strong relationships in three key
nations: India, China, and Korea. Especially in China, Maxwell has a strong
record of accomplishment. Now, he says, it’s important to create new
relationships in another region—the Middle East. “But we are going to have to
make some difficult choices,” he said, “because we simply do not have the
financial capacity to work everywhere in the world that we might find of
interest.”
Wallerstein explained that he has had preliminary conversations with (and
visited) a group in the emirate of Dubai that is working to build a new
institution of higher education “from scratch”—part of the new city-state
emerging there. He said the
Dubai
founding group seeks the cooperation of existing schools, which might generate
curricula and other programming for this new institution; and that this group
“is keenly interested in the possibility that Maxwell and Syracuse University
might join with a number of other leading universities in this new endeavor.”
He cautioned that this concept is in an exploratory stage only. Still, he said,
“the idea that, by opening a satellite campus, which notionally would be built
at no financial expense to us, Syracuse University could reach out to students
from many countries who might not otherwise ever seek admission here in the
United States holds considerable appeal.” An advisory group will be formed to
work with the dean’s office if there is further movement on this idea.
Closer to home, Wallerstein said Maxwell is also considering the possible
expansion of academic programs in Washington, D.C. Currently, the School offers
courses for both the undergraduate and graduate international relations programs
there, and for certain aspects of the M.P.A. program. Beyond that, however, the
prominence of Maxwell alumni in Washington and the School’s “extraordinarily
high brand recognition and prestige” suggest that it might be advantageous to
build on existing programs, perhaps offering the midcareer public administration
degree (the Executive M.P.A.) in Washington.
This, too, is an idea in its exploratory stage. “There are already a substantial
number of competitor institutions in and around the capital,” Wallerstein said.
“But the opportunity for people to earn a master’s degree from the nation’s
number-one ranked graduate school of public affairs, and to be able to do so on
a part-time basis at a pace dictated by the demands of their day job, might be a
powerful marketing advantage.” So as not to over-extend School resources or put
unreasonable demands on the faculty, he added, it might be possible to allow
Syracuse-based faculty members to participate by means of video teleconference.
Other instructors would be Washington-based, part-time instructors.
And Wallerstein talked about the potential for adding new degree programs to
Maxwell’s portfolio. “I am mindful of the fact that we cannot do everything. We
must be highly selective in the new programmatic initiatives we agree to take
on, whether unilaterally or in conjunction with other schools and colleges of
the University,” he said. “I believe that we should be open to pursuing new
opportunities when a really good idea comes along, but we also must be certain
that we are not leveraging ourselves beyond our prudent financial carrying
capacity.”
In closing, Wallerstein spoke approvingly of the commitment and contributions
made by the faculty and by all members of the Maxwell community during his term
thus far.
“In the words of the Oath of the Athenian Citizens that appear on the wall just
outside of this auditorium, it is my goal—and, indeed, I consider it my duty as
Maxwell Dean—to transmit the School to my eventual successor ‘greater, better,
and more beautiful’ than it was transmitted to me,” Wallerstein said. “I believe
that we have made solid progress toward this goal, and with your help and
support, I am eager to proceed with the next steps in this never-ending effort!”