A Theory of the Contributors to Estimated Regressivity in Property Assessment: From A Theme-Based Meta-Analysis
Yilin Hou
CPR Working Paper No. 298
Inequity in property taxation has been a focus of research since the 1960s, and progress has been made on several fronts. The causes of vertical inequity, however, remain a puzzle.
The latest research, using large datasets and rigorous methods, provides evidence of regressivity in value assessment and in the distribution of the tax burden, but it does not identify the components of the estimated regressivity.
This paper fills that gap with a theme-based meta-analysis of academic research. It explores the factors behind assessment regressivity and formulates a theory, with a formal model, that offers a path for empirical testing. The paper takes neither side of the debate; it only dissects the “regressivity” findings in the literature.
On theoretical grounds, it examines mismatches in the foundational measure on which the regressivity argument rests. On empirical grounds, it summarizes baselines for testing the theory, paving the way for qualifying the conclusions of existing research.